70,000+ Women Trust Our Top Pick
Over 60 Hours of Wear-Time Tested
10 Eyeliners Tested Side-by-Side
70,000+ Women Trust Our Top Pick
Over 60 Hours of Wear-Time Tested
10 Eyeliners Tested Side-by-Side
280+ top eyeliner reviews
280+ verified reviews for our #1 eyeliner pick
The Best Eyeliners for Women 40+ - Ranked & Reviewed
We tested the best eyeliners to find out what truly works. Whether you struggle with finding an eyeliner for hooded eyes or want a formula that lasts all day, our top pick is trusted by hundreds for a reason.
We tested top eyeliner pencils to see what really works. If you have hooded eyes or want all-day wear, our top pick delivers — and it's trusted for a reason.
Tested By Thousands Of Eyeliner Lovers
Tested By Thousands Of Eyeliner Lovers
Researched by the team of
Cosmetic Scientists & Beauty Specialists
The Best Eyeliner for Mature Eyes
As we age, our skin becomes thinner and more delicate - especially around the eyes.
The eyeliner that once glided on with ease may now tug, smudge, settle into fine lines, or fade far too quickly. Hooded lids, dryness, and sensitivity make finding the right product more frustrating than ever.
To cut through the noise, we tested popular options to find the best eye pencil for mature eyes - working with beauty experts, makeup artists, and real users. Some impressed us with smooth, long-lasting wear. Others didn’t hold up. But one stood out - offering the perfect balance of precision, comfort, and stay-all-day performance.
As we age, our skin becomes thinner and more delicate—especially around the eyes.
What once glided on easily may now tug, smudge, or fade too fast. Hooded lids and sensitivity make eyeliner a challenge.
So, we tested popular picks to find the best eye pencil for mature eyes - working with experts and real users to see what truly lasts.
1. LushLine+ Waterproof Eyeliner – Rumi Cosmetiques - £17.85
We tried LushLine+ and were genuinely impressed — it glides on effortlessly, stays all day, and feels incredibly gentle on mature eyes.
Trusted by 70,000+ mature women
Pros:
Specifically for mature eyes
Smudge-proof & waterproof
Gentle on sensitive eyes
Nourishes as it defines
Easy, mess-free application
Built-in sharpener + angled smudge tip
100% Money Back Guarantee
Cons:
Limited Shade Options
Premium price available only with subscription
Pros:
Specifically for mature eyes
Smudge-proof & waterproof
Gentle on sensitive eyes
Nourishes as it defines
Easy, mess-free application
Built-in sharpener
100% Money Back Guarantee
Cons:
Limited Shade Options
Premium price available only with subscription
“The Best Quality!”
"I bought the grey and brown eyeliners and have used one them every day since they arrived. Excellent quality!"
— Anne Mackay
“Best Eyeliner Ever!”
"Now my eyes look as fresh at the end of the day as they do in the morning 😉 I’ll never go back to anything else. This eyeliner is the best. Hands down."
— Andrea Burrell
“I Can Finally Wear Eyeliner!”
"Always afraid to wear makeup, went for the mature 😁 recommendation! And love it, soft and gentle on my eye lids feel great!"
— Beth Davies
“Brilliant Eye Liner”
"Really delighted with this eye liner. It glides on so easily and doesn’t smudge at all. It lasts all day too. Have the black and ordering the grey colour next time! Can highly recommend!"
— Louise F
3. Primeeyes Eyeliner - Prime Prometics
£22.00
This one impressed us with its smooth, gel-creme formula that glides effortlessly,
Cons:
Not Fully Waterproof
Require Multiple Applications
Smudge on Lower Lash Line
Limited Long-Lasting for Some
Separate Sharpener
Pros:
Easy & Precise Application
Hypoallergenic & Ophthalmologist Tested
Water-resistant and Smudge-proof
Pros:
Easy & Precise Application
Hypoallergenic & Ophthalmologist Tested
Water-resistant and Smudge-proof
Cons:
Not Fully Waterproof
Multiple Applications
Frequent Smudge on Lower Lash Line
Limited Long-Lasting for Some
Separate Sharpener
2. Satin Kajal Liner - Victoria Beckham
£32.00
We expected just fancy eyeliner — but the texture, pigment, and wear time surprised us.
Cons:
Can smudge on oily lids
Needs frequent sharpening
Some lighter shades need layering
Not widely available in offline stores
Pricey for a single pencil
Pros:
Ultra-creamy Texture
Intense Pigmentation
Long-lasting, waterproof
Excellent Shade Variety
Pros:
Ultra-creamy Texture
Intense Pigmentation
Long-lasting, waterproof
Excellent Shade Variety
Cons:
Can smudge on oily lids
Needs frequent sharpening
Some lighter shades need layering
Not widely available in offline stores
Pricey for a single pencil
5. Velvet Love Eyeliner Pencil - Zoeva
£18.50
We tested this eyeliner and loved its smooth glide — though it isn’t fully waterproof.
Cons:
Not Fully Waterproof
Requires sharpening (not retractable)
Sets too quickly
Wear time can vary
Removal takes extra effort
Frequent Sharpening
Pros:
Smooth Application
Extensive Shade Range (matte & metallic)
Versatile Application Looks
Pros:
Smooth Application
Extensive Shade Range (matte & metallic)
Versatile Application Looks
Cons:
Not Fully Waterproof
Requires sharpening (not retractable)
Sets too quickly
Wear time can vary
Removal takes extra effort
Frequent Sharpening
4. Khôl Couture Eye Pencil - Givenchy
£21.00
While the long wear impressed us, it needs sharpening often and the colour appears different than online.
Cons:
Limited shade range
Colour accuracy online
Needs proper remover
Tip can dull – requires sharpening
Runs out relatively quickly
Precision limitations:
Pros:
Smooth, creamy texture
Richly pigmented colour payoff
Blendable before setting
Great for waterline/tightlining
Pros:
Smooth, creamy texture
Richly pigmented colour payoff
Blendable before setting
Great for waterline/tightlining
Cons:
Limited shade range
Colour accuracy online
Needs proper remover
Tip can dull – requires sharpening
Runs out relatively quickly
Precision limitations:
7. Rock ‘N’ Kohl - Charlotte Tilbury
£25.00
We liked the glide and pigment — but frequent smudging make it less ideal for all-day wear.
Cons:
Requires Sharpening
Can Smudge on Some
Not Long-Lasting
Soft Tip Issues
Wears down quickly
Limited colour range
Pros:
Smooth, Creamy Application
Blendable & Versatile
Gentle on Eyes
Pros:
Smooth, Creamy Application
Blendable & Versatile
Gentle on Eyes
Cons:
Requires Sharpening
Can Smudge on Some
Not Long-Lasting
Soft Tip Issues
Wears down quickly
Limited colour range
6. Brushstroke 24-Hour Eye Liner- MAC
£18.60
We loved the clean finish — but it dries fast, flakes on some lids, and isn’t truly waterproof.
Cons:
Inconsistent 24-hour wear
Not fully waterproof
Requires a base on oily lids
Limited shade range
Can flake or crack
Not ideal for layering
Pros:
Rich pigmentation
Precise and easy application
Easy removal
Pros:
Rich pigmentation
Precise and easy application
Easy removal
Cons:
Inconsistent 24-hour wear
Not fully waterproof
Requires a base on oily lids
Limited shade range
Can flake or crack
Not ideal for layering
9. Le Stylo Waterproof Eyeliner - Lancome
£19.50
We tried this smooth, smudge-friendly liner—but it didn’t hold up like a true waterproof formula.
Cons:
Not fully waterproof
Can Smudge on Some
Not Long-Lasting
Soft Tip Issues
Can break easily
Inconsistent pigment
Pros:
Smooth, Creamy Application
Blendable & Versatile
Good for everyday wear
Pros:
Smooth, Creamy Application
Blendable & Versatile
Good for everyday wear
Cons:
Not fully waterproof
Can Smudge on Some
Not Long-Lasting
Soft Tip Issues
Can break easily
Inconsistent pigment
8. Clean Line Gel Liner - Ilia Beauty
£26.00
We loved the pigment—but the small size, smudging on oily lids, and quick tip wear hold it back.
Cons:
Can Smudge on Some Eyes
Not fully waterproof
Mixed Staying Power
Limited shade range
Can flake or crack
Can dry out over time
Pros:
Rich pigmentation
Smooth, Tug-Free Application
Long-Wearing & Budge-Resistant
Pros:
Rich pigmentation
Smooth, Tug-Free Application
Long-Wearing & Budge-Resistant
Cons:
Can Smudge on Some Eyes
Not fully waterproof
Mixed Staying Power
Limited shade range
Can flake or crack
Can dry out over time
10. All Day® Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner- Stilla
£21.00
We tried Stila eyeliner and loved the bold pigment—but it’s less forgiving on mature or dry lids and the tip can dry out quickly.
Cons:
Tip may dry out quickly
Not ideal for waterline
Hard to correct mistakes
May skip or drag on drier lids
Can dry out over time
Too bold and harsh for mature skin
Pros:
Water-resistant formula
Great for hooded or oily lids (with primer)
Pros:
Water-resistant formula
Great for hooded or oily lids (with primer)
Cons:
Tip may dry out quickly
Not ideal for waterline
Hard to correct mistakes
May skip or drag on drier lids
Can dry out over time
Too bold and harsh for mature skin
10 Eyeliners Tested
70K+ Women Surveyed
#1 Pick for Mature Eyes
dermatologically-Tested
10 Eyeliners Tested
70K+ Women Surveyed
#1 Pick for Mature Eyes
dermatologically-Tested
280+ verified reviews for our #1 eyeliner pick
Final Verdict
Best Waterproof Eye Pencil for Mature Eyes
After testing the most searched and recommended options — one product clearly stood out: LushLine+ Waterproof Eyeliner by Rumi.
Outperformed top brands – including Clinique & Stila
Perfect for hooded eyes – clean wings, no smudge
Longwear payoff – like semi permanent, but removable
See Why 70,000+ Women Swear by It
Real Women. Real Results.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Rumi LushLine+ suitable for mature or older women?
Yes — Rumi LushLine+ is the best eyeliner pencil for mature women thanks to its creamy, tug-free texture and non-irritating formula. It enhances definition without settling into fine lines, making it ideal for older women.
How does LushLine+ compare to Lancôme eyeliner?
While Lancôme eyeliner offers a bold pigment and sleek design, many users found that LushLine+ by Rumi delivers better comfort and longer-lasting wear—especially for mature or sensitive eyes. It stays put all day without smudging or irritation.
Can I use Rumi LushLine+ on sensitive eyes?
Yes — LushLine+ is a gentle eyeliner pencil for sensitive eyes, free from harsh ingredients, making it safe and comfortable for all-day wear.
Can Rumi LushLine+ create winged eyeliner for hooded eyes?
Yes — thanks to its precision tip and creamy texture, Rumi LushLine+ is perfect for creating winged eyeliner for hooded eyes that won’t crease or fade halfway through the day.
Is LushLine+ a permanent eyeliner?
No, LushLine+ is not a permanent eyeliner. It offers long-lasting, smudge-proof wear that stays in place all day — but it can be easily removed with makeup remover. You get the benefits of a semi permanent eyeliner look without the commitment or irritation of a tattoo.
Loved by Influencers & Beauty Experts
From pro artists to everyday women, see how LushLine+ delivers smooth, smudge-proof definition
Ali Martin - Beauty Content Creator empowering women 45+ with practical makeup tips
110K+ Influencer
Angela Tierney - Makeup Artist and Content creator for women 50+
50K+ Influencer
Sarah Beaman - Beauty and Skincare Enthusiast for women over 40
17K+ Influencer
Nicole Diamond - professional Makeup Artist with 30+ years of experience in beauty and skincare
26K+ Influencer
Jane Avis - Nonagenarian Style Icon, redefining beauty and fashion over 90
28K+ Influencer
🌸 Glide On Confidence, Every Day
